I have a problem. Should we call it an addiction? No. No, nevermind. Not an addiciton. Because then we would be talking 12 step programs. And I'm really just not ready to sit in a room with strangers and talk about this.
I'd much rather talk about it with you.
Cake batter.
It's like a four letter word for me. I mean, I'm not a fool. I get that it is actually two words. And while one of them happens to be four letters, the other does not.
Anyway!
Cake batter.
It all started at the end of my pregnancy with Gavin. Life felt stressful. Like super stressful. And how did I handle this stress? I baked. I was at risk for developing gestational diabetes, so I was being mindful of my sugar intake. But I somehow managed to convince myself that if I nibbled on ingredients while baking, it didn't count.
Say what now?
Yeah, you heard me.
Really everyone knows that a lick of frosting off a beater does not count towards your calorie intake for the day. It's only when you eat it a top of a cupcake that you need to think about how many calories, saturated grams of fat, and blah blah blah it contains.
It's true!
Oh my goodness! It is an addiction! Do you hear me trying to talk myself into this behavior.
Oh boy.
We're in deep people.
Really though. I've never met a cookie dough that didn't want me to eat it, or a spoon of cake batter that I wouldn't lick. If it's uncooked and contains sugar, it has my name written all over it.
And I'm not alone either.
All over Pinterest you can see recipes of "cookie dough flavored this" and "cake batter flavored that."
Well, I have another to add to the collection.
Cake Batter Cheesecake.
It's soooooo good. And strangely, it gets better after like a day. And if you eat it straight out of the pan with a fork while standing in front of the refrigerator at 9 p.m. it tastes AMAZING.
Okay. I have a problem. Admitting it is the first step. Right?
Cake Batter Cheesecake
- 3 8 oz containers of cream cheese
- 3 eggs
- 1 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk
- 1 1/2 TBSPs vanilla
- 2 tsps almond extract
- 1/2 cup of rainbow sprinkles
- 1/2 cup powdered sugar (optional)
- 1/2 TBSP whole milk (optional)
- Preheat your oven to 375 degrees.
- With your mixer on low, beat together the cream cheese, eggs, sweetened condensed milk, vanilla, and almond extract for five minutes. (It may not be completely smooth when you are done, but that's okay . . . resist the urge to eat all the batter.)
- Slowly mix in all the sprinkles with a spoon.
- Pour the batter into a spring form pan and bake for 45 minutes. Let cool completely, at least four hours in the refrigerator.
- Optional: Want to make a good dessert even better? Whisk together the powdered sugar and milk, make it festive with a little pink food coloring, and drizzle it over the cheesecake.
Want more cake flavored awesomeness?
![]() |
| Oreo Birthday Cake Pie |







OHMIGOSH YES Lisa! SO freaking delish. I'm so addicted to cake batter, I want to marry it.
ReplyDeleteOoooooh - yummy!!! (yes, you can bring the rest to my house....if you insist.... :)
ReplyDeleteI just packed up a closet for the move which included my springform pans. It's been THREE YEARS since I've baked a cheesecake and it's one of my favorite things to make!! It will be one of the inagural things made in my new open space. And now thanks to you, I can make it cake batter cheesecake and impress my three boys :)
ReplyDeleteOh this is amazing! My "Obsession" is Chicken, Bacon, Ranch. As in my sister-in-law ripped on me when I ordered it in a restaurant this weekend. Pathetic that she knows it just from reading my blog :)
ReplyDeleteLol!!
DeleteLike I said on Instagram- I need this... Now. ;)
ReplyDeleteI think I should make my Happy Birthday Cake Batter Ice Cream & you should make this & we should get together & eat them, lol!
oh my this looks and sounds divine. I too love cake batter!
ReplyDeleteNewest follower here, I found your blog through the blog hop! You have a wonderful blog, I can't wait to read more.
ReplyDeleteYou can find me at meandmr.com
-Melanie @meandmr.com
Great idea and beautiful photos! I love anything with cake batter... I'm sure this would be no different. I'd be thrilled if you'd link up at this week's Off the Hook!
ReplyDeleteThis looks so yummy!! I love your blog as well! Very colorful! I pinned and I would love it if you cold link this up at my linky party Thursday at http://www.juliakendrick.com! I hope you have a great day! Julia
ReplyDeleteThanks Julia!!! I love hearing that people like what I'm doing :)
DeleteWow, you really can't go wrong combining cheesecake and cake batter! Just pinned and stumbled.
ReplyDeleteThanks Vicky!! Seriously. What else can I make that is cake batterish???
DeleteThis looks amazing! Wow. Two things that I love best- cheesecake and cake! Yum!
ReplyDeleteLisa, this sounds absolutely mouth watering! I would love for you to share this & any other recipes at my link party: http://dessertnowdinnerlater.blogspot.com/2013/03/sweet-savory-saturdays-4.html
ReplyDeleteI hope to see you there!
~Amber @ Dessert Now, Dinner Later!
Oh my, I am speechless. I love cheesecake {it's a tie between it and brownies for the #1 spot} and I can just imagine how awesome this tastes!
ReplyDeleteHaha! Yes, everyone knows there are no calories if you eat while baking/cooking or if you eat standing up. So, you're alllll good! Love this, Lisa! I'm featuring you tonight at the Back for Seconds Social! Congrats :)
ReplyDeletelove your blog! just found you from pinterest and you described my life to a T! Hot glue and vino with something baking in the oven, all while tripping over the little people running circles around me! xo
ReplyDeleteI'm confused....so it doesn't USE any cake batter in the recipe? It just tastes like cake batter? I keep looking where to add the cake batter LOL
ReplyDeleteYup, I'm tricky like that Pamela! Lol! Although . . . now I kind of want to make a cheesecake with cake mix. :)
Delete